Grilled Cheese Bread Pudding

I love a good savory Bread Pudding. My husband loves all bread puddings, but not equally of course.  Savory bread puddings are fun because they aren’t as common, but still have the amazing texture you expect from a dessert version.  We are doing something really different though. Bread Pudding, of the savory sort, made with grilled cheese sandwiches. I don’t know how exactly my brain got here, but it went something like this:  I was thinking I should make tomato soup with the rest of a can of tomatoes; then I recalled it had only been about 9-10 days since I served grilled cheese and tomato soup for lunch; so if I was going to make soup I’d have to serve it with something different…. I can’t after all burn my family out on one of my favorite meals.  Anyways, somewhere in there I came to bread pudding.

Grilled Cheese Bread Pudding

This was a first time with this recipe for me. So we went plain. Straight-forward. No muss, no fuss. That being said, I look forward to making this again with maybe some garlic?  perhaps bacon and leeks? or caramelized onions and a tomato & panko crust? Or trying some fancier cheeses, instead of the old-school sliced cheese you grew up on. Maybe make it with Challah or Brioche? – oh there is a future of recipe testing here, indeed.

Grilled Cheese Bread Pudding

For now this version – well it tastes exactly like a grilled cheese sandwich, but in the dense and luscious form that is bread pudding.  It is fun and amazing and a great gourmet twist on the classic grilled cheese and tomato soup combo.

Grilled Cheese Bread Pudding
I apologize – I have no ingredient picture. When I decided to do this – I kinda just “went” with it in the hopes it would be amazing.
Obviously I started with bread (we chose Texas Toast) and good ol’ butter.  P.S. I love my butter bell! (or crock, as some say)


for the grilled cheese

  • about 1 stick of butter, room temperature
  • 10 slices of Texas Toast
  • 20 slices of American Cheese
    equipment griddle or large pan

for the custard

  • 2 large eggs
  • 1 1/2 cups milk
  • 1 1/2 cups heavy cream
  • 1 cup cheddar cheese, shredded
  • 1/4 tsp mustard powder
  • salt & pepper, to taste
    equipment medium sauce pan, large mixing bowl, and casserole dish


  • heaping 1/4 cup grated parmesan cheese


Grill le Cheese

Heat Griddle to 350; generously butter one side of each piece of bread and arrange on griddle top. Add one slice of cheese to each piece of bread and once they begin to melt start matching them up into sandwiches. Continue cooking, flipping when necessary, to ensure both sides get lightly browned and the cheese melts.  Set grilled cheese aside on cutting board to cool.

MMmmm Grilled Cheese

This is our version of “drying” the bread out as bread pudding is usually made with stale bread.
Tips: I usually grill both sides of my bread for grilled cheese – once you do, you’ll never go back! 

Also, prep your cheese slices in advance – it will make the cooking part go quicker and more smoothly! 

TIME TO PREHEAT YOUR OVEN: The stand 350 degrees will do.

Now for the custard:

Custard Part 1

In a medium saucepan combine: milk, heavy cream, and shredded cheese. (I like to use finely shredded – it melts faster)
Place over medium-low heat and whisk occasionally to ensure cheese melts and it doesn’t scald to bottom of pan.
About 3-5 minutes cooking time.
Once melted set aside until you are ready to temper the egg mixture.

Custard Part 2

While or after you make the cheese flavored milk part of the custard:
Combine two eggs, salt & pepper, and mustard powder – beat well.
Now once your milk portion is ready we are going to temper the eggs by adding a small portion of the milk to the eggs while whisking.
We want the heat to even out between the two otherwise it will scramble your eggs. Keep adding in small increments, while whisking, until
it is fully combined. Set custard aside while you prepare your dish.

Dish Layer 1

Butter the bottom and sides of your casserole dish with 1-2 Tbsp of butter.
I used my 10.5 inch oval dish which is 1.75qts for this dish.

Now, do you remember our beautiful Texas sized grilled cheese? Let’s chop those babies up now that they are cool:

Dish Layer 2

I quartered four of my five grilled cheese sandwiches. I started with a layer down the middle, then put 3 quarters on one side, then the other. My final grilled cheese got cut into eighths and I used the adorable little triangles to fill in random nooks and crannies. It doesn’t really matter how you slice it – it’s gonna puff up and become it’s own beautiful thing.

Dish Layer 3

Now pour on as much of the custard as possible, it won’t be all of it, but don’t fret it will fit soon…
Squish the bread down with your fingers (or a spoon…) to help it soak up the custardy goodness.
Walk away and let it sit for about 15 minutes. It will absorb all that liquid like so.

Now we can pour the rest of the custard mix on:

Dish Layer 4

You should have some bread corners and bits sticking out – it’s okay it will just brown up and be lovely.
Top your dish with grated parmesan chesse and put it on a cookie sheet – we are ready to rock and roll.

Grilled Cheese Bread Pudding

Pop that baby in the middle of your oven on a cookie sheet and
BAKE for 1 hour & 20 minutes, or until the middle is set and the top is browned.
See how it puffed up like a heavenly sandwich souffle?

It won’t last though – it deflates into a lovely bread pudding. Which is okay, because now it’s time for the best part – eating it.

Grilled Cheese Bread Pudding

We served ours with some Rich Tomato Soup I made while it was in the oven. I’ll share the recipe soon – it has a secret family ingredient I think you will love.

Grilled Cheese Bread Pudding

See all those lovely layers of custard baked bread and cheesy goodness.

Grilled Cheese Bread Pudding

This truly was a fun dish and I hope you enjoy it too.

Sincerely, ApronClad




9 Comments on “Grilled Cheese Bread Pudding

  1. Pretty nice post. I simply stumbled upon your weblog and
    wished to say that I have really enjoyed browsing your
    weblog posts. In any case I will be subscribing for your rss feed and I’m
    hoping you write again very soon!

  2. Pingback: Fried Green Tomatoes | Summer Traditions | apronclad

  3. Pingback: Saturday Sites: Week Twenty-Two |

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: